CIVIL PROCEDURE — Application for separate determination of questions — whether defendant is indemnified by insurance policy — parties agree that resolution of their dispute before the primary proceedings is in the interests of justice but disagree about the form of the separate questions — separate questions to be answered involve questions of law, no contested evidence, and involve the construction of terms in the insurance policy — separate questions will facilitate the just, quick and cheap resolution of the real issues in the proceedings
Quick Take
1Separate determination under UCPR r 28.2 is appropriate where the questions are pure questions of construction involving no contested evidence, and their resolution would either dispose of the dispute or substantially narrow the remaining issues.
2Where a s 54 Insurance Contracts Act argument requires further procedural steps (including a claim under a different policy year and amendment of pleadings) before it can be properly ventilated, it is premature to order its separate determination alongside ready construction questions.
3Early resolution of an indemnity dispute between insured and insurer can facilitate settlement of the underlying claim and avoid duplication of defence costs, supporting the overriding purpose in s 56 of the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW).