CORPORATIONS — winding up — voidable transactions — uncommercial transactions — unfair preference payments — unreasonable director-related transactions — where sole director of insolvent company used company account to hold personal funds — whether such funds beneficially belong to the company — whether sole director’s transfer of such funds to his wife diminished company assets available to creditors on a winding up
Quick Take
1Where a sole director deposits personal funds (here, proceeds of sale of personally owned property) into a company bank account with the intention that they be held for a third party, a trust may arise separating legal and beneficial ownership, such that those funds do not form part of the company's assets available to creditors on winding up — no particular formality is required to establish the trust.
2A payment made by a third party (here, a real estate agent) directly to a creditor does not constitute a transaction of the company unless the company was entitled to the benefit conferred, applying Cant v Mad Brothers Earthmoving Pty Ltd (2020) 63 VR 222.
3For an unfair preference claim under s 588FA(1) of the Corporations Act, the liquidator must prove the creditor received more than they would have on a winding up; on the facts, evidence that no dividend was likely to be paid to unsecured creditors was sufficient.