RESTITUTION — nature of restitutionary liability — quantum meruit — express or implied request — failure to establish on the evidence
CONTRACTS — Construction and interpretation — method of calculation of Service Fee due under a contract — meaning of “cost of products”
Quick Take
1A claim for restitution by way of quantum meruit requires proof of an express or implied request by the defendant for the work performed; work undertaken by a plaintiff of their own volition in pursuit of an ambition to attain a role never assigned to them does not ground such a claim, even where the plaintiff held a relevant title.
2The phrase 'cost of products' in a service fee clause in a facilities-and-services agreement between a clinic operator and an independent contractor medical practitioner is not limited to the wholesale acquisition price paid to the supplier but encompasses the broader costs of ordering, supplying, storing and maintaining those products.
3Where a plaintiff's damages case rests on forensic accounting analysis conducted on a mistaken factual premise (here, confusing amounts charged to patients with amounts charged to the doctor), the claim is not proved on the balance of probabilities.
Case Details
Citation[2026] NSWDC 280
CourtNSWDC
JurisdictionNew South Wales
Unlock so much more with Barrister AI
The full text is available to signed-in members, including the 1 later case that cites this judgment.