COSTS — claim for damages for personal injury for intentional torts in respect of institutional sexual abuse by a primary school teacher — plaintiff successful in obtaining substantial monetary judgment against the teacher — teacher ceased attending the hearing after admitting torts, whilst disputing causation and raising other defences — plaintiff’s application for costs to be awarded as a gross lump sum
COSTS — cross-claim — State successful in recovering order for full indemnity for its liability to the plaintiff and its own claim for damages for breach of employment contract for costs of defending that proceeding — State’s application for indemnity costs — non-acceptance of an offer to contribute — asserted unreasonable conduct by cross-defendant in defence of litigation — State’s application for costs to be awarded as gross lump sum
Quick Take
1A gross sum costs order under s 98(4)(c) CPA is more readily justified where the successful party has a strong imperative to avoid further engagement with the opposing party (here, an institutional abuse survivor and her incarcerated abuser), the costs claimed are conservative and transparent, and the opposing party's unpredictable litigation conduct makes the assessment process uncertain.
2An unreasonable failure to accept an offer to contribute under UCPR r 20.32, treated analogously to a Calderbank offer following [name withheld] v [name withheld] (No 4), justifies indemnity costs from the date after the offer, but the cross-defendant's broader litigation conduct — including raising defences ultimately rejected — did not alone warrant indemnity costs where no prior warning of such an application was given and the defences were not all legally untenable.
3A gross sum costs order was declined for the State where the anticipated costs assessment was not expected to be protracted or expensive, the opposing party's passivity would likely expedite rather than hinder assessment, and the court was not satisfied the cross-defendant would not be worse off under a gross sum order than on assessment.