CIVIL PROCEDURE — Stay of proceedings — application made under s 20 of the Service and Execution of Process Act 1992 (Cth) and r 12.11(1) Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW)
Quick Take
1On an interlocutory application for a stay under s 20(3) SEPA, before the court may rely on an exclusive jurisdiction agreement as a factor under s 20(4)(d), it must be satisfied there is at least a strong prima facie case that the agreement exists and applies to the relevant proceedings; where the evidence supports reasonable arguments both ways, the applicant for the stay has not discharged its onus.
2An exclusive jurisdiction clause selecting a court that has jurisdiction under the ACL does not, in the court's view, amount to contracting out of ACL statutory remedies or offend public policy, though this was not finally determined.
3Where a stay would expose the plaintiff to an accrued limitation defence and the defendant has not proposed or consented to any specific condition to ameliorate that prejudice, the court is not obliged to fashion such a condition itself, and the limitation issue provides an independent basis to refuse the stay.