CIVIL PROCEDURE — settlement approval of settlement involving an elderly man with brain injuries — whether settlement is in best interests of plaintiff
Quick Take
1When approving a settlement involving a person under legal incapacity under s 76 of the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW), the Court's function is protective: the question is whether the proposed settlement is beneficial to the interests of the plaintiff or in his best interests, having regard to litigation risk, the desirability of early finality, and the avoidance of further distress.
2Where a plaintiff under incapacity is elderly and terminally ill, the Court may permit settlement moneys to be paid to a family member holding power of attorney to be held on trust for the plaintiff's benefit, following the approach in [name withheld] by his tutor Dopper v Western NSW Local Health District [2026] NSWSC 878.
3The Court will not enforce a compromise against the opinion of the tutor and the plaintiff's legal adviser, but must independently form its own view as to whether the settlement is in the plaintiff's best interests.