CONTRACTS — Terms — claim for payment for work performed under two contracts — disagreement as to terms of both contracts as to price — whether failure of consideration established — whether one of the contracts was terminated — whether the plaintiff was in breach of either contract
NEGLIGENCE — Proof of negligence — allegation in cross-claim that the plaintiff performed work negligently causing loss and damage to the cross-claimant
Quick Take
1A contractor's written quotation may be accepted by the recipient's conduct, without any signed acceptance. On the facts, telling the contractor when to attend site and arranging for the works to proceed was acceptance, so the contract incorporated the quotation's price and standard terms, including additional charges for pile extensions.
2A party alleging breach of a construction subcontract must point to an express or implied term. Where a quotation was silent on timing, safety procedures, personal protective equipment and track mats, no breach was established by complaints about late arrival, missing equipment or failure to supply track mats.
3Under ss 5B and 5E of the Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW), a cross-claimant alleging negligent damage to a service conduit must identify precautions a reasonable person in the contractor's position would have taken and prove causation. On the facts, the claim failed where the head contractor had set the pile location over the exposed conduit, dug an inadequate trench and directed angled installation, and where alleged lost future work and rectification costs were not causally linked to the contractor's conduct or had been recouped from the principal.