COSTS — Exceptions to general rule that costs follow the event — Offers of compromise/Calderbank offer — Whether proper basis for indemnity costs
COSTS — Claim succeeding against one defendant only — Sanderson Orders — Whether preconditions satisfied
Quick Take
1A Sanderson order requires both that it was reasonable to sue the successful defendant and that the unsuccessful defendant's conduct makes it fair to impose liability for the successful defendant's costs. A mere denial of liability by the unsuccessful defendant, or a defence (such as accord and satisfaction) equally relevant to both defendants, is insufficient absent something more, such as a positive assertion that the other defendant was liable.
2That the claim ultimately pressed against a successful defendant was weak or briefly argued does not disentitle that defendant to costs on the ordinary basis; allocation of costs between jointly represented defendants is a matter for assessment.
3Pre-proceedings correspondence that does not specify a sum, does not clearly identify the offeror as the plaintiff, and (if for the full debt without interest) involves no genuine compromise is not a clear offer capable of acceptance, and on the facts its non-acceptance was not unreasonable so as to justify indemnity costs.