The Court imposed an aggregate sentence of 10 years' imprisonment (NPP 6 years) for multiple intimidation, knife, and police assault offences committed while on parole, finding that the offender's severe childhood deprivation (Bugmy), complex PTSD, and substance use disorder materially reduced moral culpability and diminished the weight of general and specific deterrence, but that community protection warranted significant weight given the offender's extensive criminal history and high reoffending risk. The guilty plea discount was reduced from 25% to 20% on one charge where a factual contest required witnesses to be called, diminishing the utilitarian value of the plea. The Court also recommended a psychiatric treatment plan as a condition of parole, noting the limitations of the criminal justice system in addressing offenders with entrenched mental health and addiction issues.
The full text is available to signed-in members.