The Court held that ASMOF's deliberate defiance of dispute orders by organising a three-day doctors' strike warranted a penalty of $30,500 (61% of the $50,000 maximum), treating the conduct from 2 to 10 April 2025 as a single course of conduct. The Court held that a union's motivation to compel a party to resume mutual gains bargaining under Chapter 2A of the IR Act carries no exculpatory or mitigatory significance because coercion is fundamentally inconsistent with the cooperative, consensus-seeking nature of mutual gains bargaining enshrined in s 129L, and because the statutory scheme contemplates orderly transition of unresolved bargaining into conventional conciliation and arbitration under Chapter 3 rather than resort to industrial force. The penalty was tempered below what might otherwise have been imposed because ASMOF had subsequently embraced the Commission's arbitral processes, but the absence of genuine contrition and the flagrant nature of the defiance required substantial weight be given to both general and specific deterrence.
The full text is available to signed-in members.