JUDGMENTS AND ORDERS — Where Industrial Relations Commission in Court Session issued two judgments without jurisdiction — Where Industrial Relations Commission in Court Session is superior court of record — Whether the judgments are void ab initio — Where applicant argues that loss of ability to seek reconsideration pursuant to s 142J of District Court Act 1973 (NSW) is a fundamental error
JUDGMENTS AND ORDERS — Amending, varying and setting aside — For irregularity — Where Industrial Relations Commission in Court Session issued two judgments without jurisdiction — Where the applicant sought to set aside those judgments pursuant to r 36.15 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW) — Whether the Court should exercise its discretion to set aside those judgments — Discretionary factors — Finality of litigation — Prejudice — Prospects of success on redetermination
CIVIL PROCEDURE — Jurisdiction — Inherent jurisdiction — Whether the Industrial Court has inherent powers
Quick Take
1Orders of the Industrial Relations Commission in Court Session, as a superior court of record under s 152 of the Industrial Relations Act 1996 (NSW), are valid until set aside even if made without jurisdiction. Loss of the opportunity to seek reconsideration under s 142J(2) of the District Court Act 1973 (NSW) is not a 'fundamental' irregularity giving an unconditional right, ex debito justitiae, to have them set aside. Section 142J(2) confers a discretionary power on the court, not a right on the litigant.
2The Industrial Court, as a statutory court, has no inherent jurisdiction to set aside its perfected judgments. It does have power under UCPR r 36.15, because Part 36 is not excluded by UCPR Sch 1 or the Industrial Relations Commission Rules. 'Court' in r 36.15 is construed ambulatorily so that a single judge may set aside orders of a Full Bench of the Industrial Court.
3Although a judgment entered without jurisdiction engages r 36.15 as made 'irregularly' or 'illegally', the discretion requires 'sufficient cause'. On the facts, finality of litigation and the limited prejudice to a claimant who received two merits hearings in the forum then universally understood to be correct outweighed the lost opportunity of reconsideration, and setting aside was refused.