CIVIL PROCEDURE — determination of separate question — whether erection and use of rear building constituted an existing use for the purposes of Div 4.11 of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW) — whether use for dual occupancy (detached) was prohibited under Canterbury-Bankstown Local Environmental Plan 2023 — use permissible with consent
Quick Take
1For a use to be an existing use within s 4.65(a) of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW), an environmental planning instrument currently in force must have the effect of prohibiting the use. If the current instrument makes the use permissible with consent, no further inquiry into historical planning instruments is warranted (applying BYT Nominees Pty Ltd v North Sydney Council (2008) 161 LGERA 77 at [26]-[29]).
2Whether a use is prohibited under an LEP requires consideration of the instrument as a whole. A use not listed in the Land Use Table, and so apparently prohibited, may be permissible with consent under an additional permitted use clause such as cl 2.5 and Sch 1 cl 26 of the Canterbury-Bankstown Local Environmental Plan 2023, which operate despite the Land Use Table.
3A party claiming existing use rights bears the onus of establishing, on the evidence, a prohibiting instrument. On the facts, the applicants identified no instrument prohibiting the dual occupancy (detached), and conceded that the earlier instruments in force while the rear dwelling was occupied permitted it with consent.