PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE — application to strike out judicial review summons upheld — challenge to various instruments filed more than three months after decisions to issue instruments by local council and certifier enabling construction of dwelling house — dwelling house built and occupied — exercise of discretion not to allow extension of time to commence judicial review proceedings — no jurisdiction to hear judicial review of approval issued by local council under Roads Act 1993 (NSW) — no leave to replead summons for modified construction certificate in light of r 59.4 Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW)
Quick Take
1Rule 59.10 of the UCPR is a stand-alone time limit, separate from s 4.59 of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979, and applies even where jurisdictional error is alleged. The fact that s 4.59 time has not begun to run, because the consent was never publicly notified, does not displace it. The applicant bears the onus of justifying an extension of time.
2When deciding whether to extend time under r 59.10(2), substantial prejudice to owners who have completed and occupied a dwelling in reliance on the approvals weighs heavily against an extension, as does the public interest in certainty in the planning system. On the facts, the following did not adequately explain the delay: a self-represented neighbour's long-standing awareness of the development, her pursuit of complaints with the council, and her ignorance of the rule. This was so even where the delay for one modification was only 36 days. Refusing the extension meant no reasonable cause of action was disclosed.
3An approval granted by a council as roads authority under s 138 of the Roads Act 1993 is not an exercise of a function under a 'planning or environmental law' in s 20(3) of the Land and Environment Court Act 1979, where it is made on a separate application and not as integrated development. It is therefore outside the Court's Class 4 judicial review jurisdiction. Several other points also follow. Grounds of review must identify, instrument by instrument, the specific breaches relied on (r 59.4). Requests for court-appointed experts and complaints about enforcement inaction are not available in judicial review.