Rumba Properties Pty Limited as trustee for the Rumba (Australia) Trust v Valuer General of New South Wales [2026] NSWLEC 144 — Valuation Of Land & Statutory Construction — Barrister AI
Rumba Properties Pty Limited as trustee for the Rumba (Australia) Trust v Valuer General of New South Wales
VALUATION OF LAND — land owner’s challenge to assessments of land value determined by the Valuer General — choice of comparable sales evidence — whether vacant land or improved land reflects appropriate comparable sales — reliability of adjustments for “added value of improvements” — whether heritage improved land reflects appropriate comparable sales — extent of adjustments for location; topography; views; shape; size — appeals upheld
STATUTORY CONSTRUCTION — whether on an appeal the Valuer General requires leave to contend for land value that differs from previous determination — leave in the circumstances not required — leave would be granted in any event
Quick Take
1On a s 37(1) appeal under the Valuation of Land Act 1916 (NSW), the Valuer General arguably does not need leave to contend for a land value lower than its objection determination (but higher than the objector's), because ss 35B(1), 35C(2), 39 and 40(1)(b), and the rehearing nature of the appeal under s 39(3) of the Land and Environment Court Act 1979, contemplate such outcomes; the Court expressed this view tentatively and would in any event have granted leave. Any such positive case should nonetheless be pleaded in the contentions as a matter of procedural fairness.
2Vacant land sales are generally the best evidence of land value under s 6A(1), but lightly improved sales are reliable comparables, and use of Rawlinsons or the Valuer General's AVOI tables to deduct the added value of improvements does not inherently produce unreliability, particularly for modest improvements; very large cumulative adjustments diminish the weight of a vacant land comparable.
3On the facts, where land is valued as two separate parts under s 14A(4), one heritage-restricted under s 14G, heritage-listed sales were the best comparables for the heritage part (with a 10% downward adjustment for their extension potential), and a 10% 'in one line' discount was preferred to a hypothetical development calculation producing a 26% discount, which a willing but not anxious vendor would not accept.