MODIFICATION APPLICATION — application to modify dwell time of existing LED signage — s 4.55(2) of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW) — whether substantially the same development
Quick Take
1The comparative exercise under s 4.55(2)(a) of the EPA Act requires a holistic assessment of both the physical and qualitative features of the originally approved and modified developments, including the use of the land and not merely the physical components; where the area of a sign increases by approximately 48%, the sign is repositioned to protrude into the road reserve and above the parapet, and the display technology changes from a manually changed static vinyl banner to an internally illuminated LED display with a 25-second dwell time permitting over 2,400 images per day, the character and essence of the development may be found to have changed such that the precondition in s 4.55(2)(a) is not met.
2Loose-leaf lighting brochures and specification documents found on a council file, without any reference in the development application form, statement of environmental effects, approved plans, or conditions of consent, do not without further evidence establish that illumination formed part of the approved development proposal incorporated by a condition requiring compliance with the 'proposals described in' the development application.
3A construction certificate and its approved plans do not form part of a development consent for the purposes of s 4.55 modification applications, by operation of s 4.16(12) of the EPA Act.