DIRECTORS’ DUTIES — where ASIC contends that the Second Defendant failed to discharge his directors’ duties and contravened s 180 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) by failing to take reasonable steps to ensure the First Defendant complied with its obligations when making an ASX announcement and was involved in continuous disclosure breaches — where Second Defendant admits liability
CORPORATIONS — where Second Defendant admits alleged contraventions — where parties prepared a statement of agreed facts and jointly proposed declarations of contravention and a pecuniary penalty — whether declaratory relief should be granted — whether proposed period of disqualification is appropriate — whether proposed pecuniary penalty is an appropriate penalty
Quick Take
1Where a director who is also CEO and executive chairman is closely involved in drafting and authorising a forward-looking profit representation without reasonable grounds, and subsequently fails to correct it or ensure continuous disclosure compliance, that conduct constitutes serious contraventions of both s 180(1) and s 674A(3) of the Corporations Act.
2In multi-party civil penalty proceedings, admissions and agreed facts between the regulator and one respondent are to be assessed on their own terms for the purpose of relief against that respondent, irrespective of different findings reached against other respondents at a contested hearing, and there is no logical inconsistency where the admitting party accepts liability from an earlier date than was established against co-respondents.
3A jointly proposed penalty that falls within the permissible range will be accepted by the court, which will not depart from the agreed figure merely because it might otherwise have selected a different amount, consistent with the public policy of promoting predictability and encouraging early resolution of civil penalty proceedings.