COSTS — party/party — indemnity costs order — where offer of compromise made — no question of principle
COSTS — gross sum costs order — where sufficient information before the Court to enable the assessment of a gross sum costs order — where desirable to avoid the expense of a costs assessment — gross sum costs order made
Quick Take
1A defendant's 'walk away' offer of compromise (verdict for the defendant with each party bearing own costs) may contain a genuine element of compromise where the proceedings have been prepared to a relatively advanced stage and the defendant has already incurred significant costs by the time the offer is made.
2Adverse credibility findings against a plaintiff — particularly where the plaintiff's case depended on accounts found to be deliberately deceitful — are a factor favouring the exercise of the discretion to award indemnity costs following an unaccepted offer of compromise.
3A gross sum costs order under s 98(4)(c) of the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW) may be made where the court has sufficient material to ascertain a fair sum, a contested costs assessment would be protracted and expensive, and the sum sought represents a substantial discount on actual solicitor/client costs.