COSTS — proceedings resolved without a hearing on the merits — blow by blow account from parties as to what occurred — encroaching structures on adjoining residential land — defendants accepted boundary determination and agreed to remove encroachments before commencement of proceedings — removal not completed within initially indicated timeframe — successive rectification works and surveys during proceedings — whether commencement and continuation of proceedings reasonable — whether defendants acted unreasonably — whether eventual removal constituted capitulation — where plaintiff obtained principal relief but did not pursue additional claims — proceedings dismissed following resolution of substantive dispute — each party to pay their own costs of the proceedings
Quick Take
1Where proceedings end without a determination on the merits, the usual order is no order as to costs if both parties acted reasonably. A plaintiff's practical success in obtaining the substance of the relief sought does not by itself justify a costs order; unreasonable conduct by the defendant must be shown, and the court will not conduct a hypothetical trial or resolve substantial evidentiary conflicts to decide costs (Re Minister for Immigration & Ethnic Affairs; Ex parte [name withheld]; [name withheld] v NFS Agribusiness Pty Ltd).
2A finding of capitulation or surrender requires a prior position of opposition. Defendants who accepted a boundary determination and undertook to remove encroachments before proceedings began, and then completed that removal, merely did what they had always said they would do and did not capitulate.
3On the facts, delay in removing minor encroachments from structures in place since 1984 was not unreasonable conduct warranting an adverse costs order. The delay arose from contractor unavailability, work on the wrong post and successive competing surveys, and there was no indication of refusal and no urgency. The plaintiff's abandonment of her additional trespass and aggravated damages claims also weighed against her recovering costs, as did the default rule in UCPR r 42.20 on dismissal, which the court departed from in ordering each party to bear their own costs.