WILLS PROBATE AND ADMINISTRATION — Making and construction of a will — Specific gift of real property — Ademption by contract — Conditional contract for sale of property — Death of vendor activates a right of rescission — Non-availability of unconditional order for specific performance of contract — No ademption — Role of statute and equity
Quick Take
1A testamentary direction to sell land and divide the net sale proceeds is a gift of proceeds, not of the land in specie, so a pre-death contract to sell that land does not cause the gift to adeem; the subject matter of the gift remains identifiable in the estate.
2Ademption by contract (via equitable conversion) occurs only if, immediately before death, equity would have ordered specific performance of the obligation to transfer conditional on nothing more than payment of the price ([name withheld] v [name withheld]). A contract that gives the vendor's estate a right of rescission on the vendor's death, with completion not yet due, does not meet that test.
3Under ss 4, 29 and 30 of the Succession Act 2006 (NSW), a will speaks as at death and passes any remaining interest the testator holds, including legal title and contractual rights such as a right to rescind or receive the price. This diminishes the significance of the real/personal property distinction and of the [name withheld] v [name withheld] propositions that treat ademption as effected at the date of contract.