CIVIL PROCEDURE — Subpoenas — Objection to production of documents or things — Client legal privilege — no issue of principle
Quick Take
1Client legal privilege under ss 118 and 119 of the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW) and settlement privilege under s 131(1)(a) is lost over communications whose substance the client has voluntarily disclosed, under s 122(3)(a). Here, the disclosure occurred through the plaintiff's own evidence under cross-examination about who had told her where sale proceeds went.
2On the facts, a solicitor's text message urging a property sale and settlement was not privileged. The party claiming privilege bears the onus of establishing the dominant purpose, and that onus was not discharged where the dominant purpose appeared to be to benefit the then-solicitors rather than to provide legal advice, legal services or settlement negotiation.
3The Court expressed concern, but left open, whether communications by a solicitor to a client-witness while she was under cross-examination could fall within the s 125(1)(a) exception as involving potential interference with the administration of justice. It was unnecessary to decide because privilege was already lost by voluntary disclosure.