CONTRACTS — Construction — Interpretation — Where plaintiff is a special purpose vehicle for the purpose of financing defendant’s purchase of property — Where ‘GST refund letter’ executed by defendant and plaintiff included an undertaking by defendant to pay plaintiff an amount representing a GST refund received in relation to the purchase — Where parties related to plaintiff and defendant subsequently entered into a term sheet in relation to the financing arrangement — Where term sheet did not mention the defendant’s obligation under the GST refund letter — Where defendant has not discharged obligation under GST refund letter — Whether GST refund letter is binding and enforceable — Whether GST refund letter was superseded by subsequent term sheet
CONTEMPT — Civil contempt — Breach of orders — Where an interlocutory injunction was ordered which required defendant to pay the amount the subject of these proceedings into a solicitor’s trust account — Where there is continuing and unexplained non-compliance with order
Quick Take
1A subsequent term sheet does not displace an earlier binding undertaking where the undertaking party was not a party to the term sheet, the term sheet only summarised principal commercial terms and expressly contemplated other agreements, and it did not purport to deal exhaustively with the parties' obligations; on the facts, references in the term sheet to the investor being satisfied its return was assured and to the return being 'as agreed' were consistent with the continued operation of the GST undertaking.
2Where an undertaking expressly characterises a payment as an 'arranger fee', the payor cannot recharacterise it as security for a loan (so as to argue inconsistency with a later security term) absent textual or evidentiary support; on the evidence the payment was required to fund the investor's additional return.
3Specific performance of an unsecured obligation to pay a sum of money will ordinarily be refused because damages are adequate, the onus being on the plaintiff to prove inadequacy. In obiter, any doubt about punishing non-payment of a judgment debt as contempt does not extend to an interlocutory asset-preservation order requiring funds to be paid into a trust account, the wilful breach of which is capable of constituting contempt; the Court did not finally determine the contempt question.