COSTS — Party/Party — application to vary costs orders — exercise of discretion — plaintiff’s impecuniosity not a relevant consideration — exemption of costs of preparation of recently served affidavit
Quick Take
1A party's impecuniosity, without more, is not a basis for declining to make or for varying an adverse costs order, since inability to pay does not render the creation of a costs debt futile (Northern Territory v Sangare (2019) 265 CLR 164 at [35]).
2The broad costs discretion does not displace the fundamental principle that an unsuccessful plaintiff bears the successful party's costs; that the defendant is a public authority represented by the Crown Solicitor, that the plaintiff is an individual, or that the proceedings were a bona fide public law challenge do not alone justify departure.
3On the facts, a hearing estimated at two days but completed in one did not warrant reducing the costs order, although the position might differ where a much longer estimate is substantially undershot; the costs of preparing an affidavit served close to the hearing, which was not permitted to be read in full, were excluded from the costs order.