CORPORATIONS — statutory demand — application to set aside — whether there is a genuine dispute about existence or amount of debt
Quick Take
1A genuine dispute about the existence of a debt under s 459H(1)(a) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) may arise from a dispute as to the identity of the contracting party. Here the company contended its loan was with an intermediary rather than with the demanding creditor, even though the creditor paid the funds and received the interest payments. On the facts, that dispute was genuine where no executed loan agreement was in evidence and there was no contemporaneous acknowledgement by the company of a relationship with the creditor.
2A submission that a dispute is a late invention, made only under the pressure of the demand (Creata; [name withheld]), has considerably less force where the debtor never previously acknowledged the asserted legal relationship and the relevant communications occurred only between the creditor and a third party.
3In an application to set aside a statutory demand, the court does not assess the deponent's credit except in extreme cases, nor weigh the relative strength of the parties' positions. A dispute may be genuine although the court has no affirmative confidence in the applicant's evidence, if the contention is not implausible.