CIVIL PROCEDURE — Notice to produce — Before hearing — Application to set aside notice to produce — Notice to produce set aside
Quick Take
1A notice to produce demanding 'all unredacted information' about a party over a period, with listed categories expressed to be merely inclusive, fails the requirement in UCPR r 21.10(1)(b) that documents be specific, clearly identified and relevant to a fact in issue. Such a notice is tantamount to discovery and constitutes a fishing expedition.
2Using a notice to produce to obtain, in effect, discovery in judicial review proceedings may be an abuse of process. It circumvents the requirement for leave under UCPR r 59.7(4) and the usual practice that discovery awaits finalised pleadings and filed evidence.
3In judicial review of prison disciplinary decisions, documents not before the decision-maker will generally lack relevance, given the limited ambit of review. Documents relating to decisions the respondent has conceded should be quashed are no longer relevant, though they may be sought on any remitter.