1The power under s 98(4)(c) of the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW) to make a gross sum costs order should be exercised only where the Court can do so fairly between the parties. That includes having confidence that an appropriate sum can be arrived at on the available material (Gabrielle v Aboud (No 4) [2023] NSWCA 100 at [6]).
2A costs debtor's asserted proprietary or other claims to monies held by the costs creditor are no basis for directing that a gross sum costs order be paid out of those monies. Such claims raise factual and legal matters not before the costs court and must be pursued in an appropriate forum.
3On the facts, a gross sum order was not deferred pending a foreign arbitration because the issues decided were discrete. Neither the defendants' success nor the resulting costs order was contingent on the outcome of later proceedings.