COSTS — unreasonable failure to accept a Calderbank offer — circumstances in which a gross sum costs order may be made — no issue of principle
Quick Take
1Failure to accept a Calderbank offer warrants indemnity costs where the offer was a genuine compromise and non-acceptance was unreasonable, assessed at the date of the offer. On the facts, non-acceptance of an offer made on the eve of trial was unreasonable where the offer was double an earlier offer, allowed four weeks for consideration, expressly invoked Calderbank, identified the central flaw in the offeree's case, and included foregoing an adverse costs order.
2An offer to forego an adverse costs order is a valuable component of a Calderbank offer, particularly where the offeree's case is likely to fail. Its value includes money already paid into court as security, even if the offeree could not otherwise meet a costs order.
3A court will not make a gross sum order applying security money in full satisfaction of competing costs orders, despite the overriding purpose of just, quick and cheap resolution, where there is no evidential basis for finding it just. Here the defendants' solicitor/client costs far exceeded the security, and there was no evidence of the quantum of the opposing costs entitlements.