CONTRACTS — construction — loan facility constituted by loan note deed and separate subscription agreements — subsequent super senior debt facility — whether unanimous consent of existing noteholders was required — acceptance of “Permitted Security” distinguished from amendment or waiver — definition not confined to security disclosed to and accepted by Majority Agents before date of deed or first utilisation — negative pledge operating prospectively — Majority Agents determined by reference to lenders’ exposures from time to time
CONTRACTS — construction — consent required for changes to “priority or order of payment” — super senior security did not change nature or scope of secured property — priority governed by subsequent priority deed — amendment and waiver provisions not engaged
TRUSTS — security trust — security interests held by trustee — noteholders held beneficial interests — trustee party to priority deed — no relief sought setting aside priority deed — distinction between trustee’s security interests and beneficiaries’ interests
CONTRACTS — sharing recoveries — separate subscription agreements — credit bid by super senior lenders — terms and identity of agents under other agreements not established — plaintiffs not parties to other agreements — no basis for enforcement — recoveries applied to super senior debt — sharing provision under original facility not engaged
Quick Take
1A clause requiring specified consents for an amendment or waiver of 'any term' of a facility deed bears its ordinary meaning of a subsequent agreement varying the deed's terms or waiving a right arising from breach; the exercise of a power or permission conferred by the deed, such as majority acceptance of security as 'Permitted Security', does not amend the deed and does not engage the unanimous-consent exceptions.
2A negative pledge exception for security 'which has been disclosed in writing by an Obligor to, and accepted by, the Majority Agents' operates prospectively: it is satisfied if disclosure and acceptance occur by the time the security is created or the exception relied upon, and is not confined to security accepted at the date of the deed or of first utilisation, particularly where 'Majority Agents' is defined by reference to lenders' exposures from time to time.
3A sacred-rights protection against 'changing the priority or order of payment' refers to the priority of payment (the payment waterfall), not the ranking of security; and where subordination of an existing facility's security is effected by a priority deed executed by the security trustee, it does not change the 'nature or scope' of the Secured Property, nor does it alter beneficiaries' interests under the security trust absent a challenge to the priority deed.