The Court dismissed the defendants' motion to compel production, holding that the Notice to Produce failed to comply with either limb of r 21.10 UCPR. Under the first limb, the documents sought were not referred to in any originating process, pleading, affidavit or witness statement of the plaintiff. Under the second limb, the notice sought broad categories of documents (all bank statements, all documents evidencing inheritance, vehicle ownership etc.) rather than specific, clearly identified documents, and in any event the plaintiff's financial position had no relevance to any fact in issue in the cross-vesting application before the Court.
The full text is available to signed-in members.