OCCUPATIONS — Legal practitioners — Legal Practitioners Fidelity Fund — Claims against fund — Where no “trust property” — Where no “pecuniary loss” — Where no “fraudulent dealings” — Where no “default” by legal practitioners — Claims dismissed
COURTS AND JUDGES — Bias — Actual bias — Applications for recusal — Where no matter raised by the plaintiff that established actual bias — Where plaintiff unable to point to any evidence of prejudgment — First and second recusal applications rejected
CIVIL PROCEDURE — Summary disposal — Summary judgment — Defendant not required to file a defence or response to summons — Defendant had at least arguable answers to relief sought
Quick Take
1Costs orders made against a claimant do not constitute 'trust property' within s 128 of the Legal Profession Uniform Law 2014 (NSW); the benefit of a costs order is a chose in action belonging to the party in whose favour it was made, not property entrusted to the solicitors who enforce it, and a debtor under a costs order has no proprietorial interest in that property for Fidelity Fund purposes.
2Money paid to a law practice for legal services already provided and billed falls within the s 129(2)(a) exception and is not 'trust money'; even where money is received before services are provided, once applied to costs lawfully owed there is no 'default' under s 219 absent a failure to pay or deliver in accordance with instructions involving fraud or dishonesty.
3A statutory appeal under s 247 of the Uniform Law is not a proceeding for judicial review within UCPR Pt 59 (r 59.1), so a defendant is not required to file a response under r 59.6; nor is a defence required under r 14.3 where proceedings are commenced by summons rather than statement of claim.
Case Details
Citation[2026] NSWSC 987
CourtNSWSC
JurisdictionNew South Wales
Unlock so much more with Barrister AI
The full text is available to signed-in members, including the 1 later case that cites this judgment.