The Court of Appeal held that a head sentence of four years' imprisonment suspended after 12 months for drug trafficking (with concurrent sentences for related offences) was not manifestly excessive, notwithstanding the applicant's early guilty pleas and significant cooperation as a registered human source under s 13B of the Penalties and Sentences Act 1992 (Qld). The Court confirmed that the 'usual' one-third discount for an early guilty plea is a general guide only and cannot be elevated to a fixed rule, and that the increase in the maximum penalty for trafficking from 25 years to life imprisonment (effective May 2023) is a relevant factor supporting higher sentences even for otherwise comparable offending. The Court also emphasised that a refused leave application (R v EU) does not establish any particular point in the range of acceptable sentences and has limited comparative utility.
The full text is available to signed-in members.