The Tribunal ordered each party to bear its own costs, refusing the applicant water retailer's claim for $366,334.47 in costs despite the applicant having succeeded in having the respondent's water pricing determination set aside and remitted. The key propositions are: (1) the public interest underpinning administrative review weighs against awarding costs merely because of jurisdictional or procedural error, as the purpose of administrative review is rectitude in decision-making, not compensation for wrongs; (2) a decision-maker's jurisdictional error, absent bad faith, does not constitute unreasonable conduct warranting a costs order; (3) a decision-maker's failure to compromise at a compulsory conference does not evidence unreasonable intransigence given the public interest obligations governing administrative decision-making; and (4) pre-commencement conduct such as delay in making the original decision falls outside the Tribunal's costs remit. The commercial complexity and expense of proceedings does not create a sub-class of reviews more amenable to costs awards, as this would undermine the legislature's choice to apply the default no-costs position.
The full text is available to signed-in members.