› Working with children check — prohibition notice — unacceptable risk to children
Administrative Law
› Child Protection
› Assessable information — weighting of criminal convictions and withdrawn charges
Evidence
› Standard of Proof
› [name withheld] principle — statutory satisfaction — not balance of probabilities
Quick Take
1Withdrawn criminal charges may be given moderate to high weight in a working with children risk assessment where the Tribunal cannot be satisfied that the underlying conduct did not occur, with the weighting reduced to reflect the possibility the conduct did not happen, consistent with the [name withheld] framework and [name withheld] caution.
2A prolonged pattern of offending demonstrating limited insight, poor impulse control, substance abuse and repeated disregard for legal obligations can establish an unacceptable risk to children even where no offending was directed at children, because such conduct reflects a dysfunctional or hazardous lifestyle within the meaning of the [name withheld] guidelines.
3Undated, unsigned and unsworn character references, particularly where the authors were not called to give evidence and were apparently unaware of the applicant's criminal history, attract minimal weight in the evaluative risk assessment.