› Allegations of improper conduct — Clause 6(2) — Unreasonableness of disclosure
Administrative law
› Freedom of information
› Internal working documents — Clause 9(1) — Public interest
Administrative law
› Freedom of information
› Operations of agencies — Clause 16(1)(a)(iii) — Substantial adverse effect on personnel management
Quick Take
1The phrase 'other improper conduct' in clause 6(2) of Schedule 1 of the FOI Act extends well beyond criminal or unlawful conduct to encompass dishonest, unethical, unreasonable or unprofessional behaviour, and 'judicial process' refers to any formal process requiring procedural fairness, not exclusively court proceedings.
2Disclosure of a preliminary workplace investigation report containing one-sided, untested allegations — where the subjects were not interviewed and the allegations were ultimately unsubstantiated — is unreasonable under clause 6(2) and contrary to the public interest under clauses 9(1) and 16(1)(a)(iii), particularly given that FOI disclosure is disclosure to the world at large.
3Staff confidence in the confidentiality and procedural fairness of an agency's grievance processes is a weighty public interest consideration; premature release of incomplete investigatory material can reasonably be expected to have a substantial adverse effect on personnel management.