On internal review, the Tribunal set aside the original order refusing termination and ordered that the tenant's tenancy be terminated, with a suspended order for vacant possession allowing the tenant until 17 April 2026 to vacate. The Tribunal applied the multi-factor discretionary framework from JXS v South Australian Housing Trust [2025] SACAT 24 to weigh the seriousness, persistence and impact of the tenant's verbal abuse of landlord staff and contractors against the tenant's vulnerability and mental health issues, concluding that the extreme and sustained nature of the abuse, the tenant's complete lack of insight, the absence of any workable management mechanism, and the adverse impact on the landlord's ability to manage the housing complex left no option but termination. The decision confirms that orders styled as 'Directions' may be substantive decisions reviewable under s 70 of the SACAT Act where they effectively determine an application on the merits, and that a social housing landlord's greater tolerance for tenants with mental health issues does not amount to an obligation to maintain a tenancy regardless of the severity and persistence of breach.
The full text is available to signed-in members.