The Tribunal affirmed the Detaining for Assessment and the assessment order, affirmed the physical restraint as lawful under s 57(4), but found that the chemical and mechanical restraint of the applicant was unauthorised and constituted a serious breach of the Act; the Urgent Circumstances Treatment authorisation was found invalid as it was not completed by an approved medical practitioner. The Tribunal made recommendations for education and training directed to the Secretary of the Department of Health and the Chief Psychiatrist. Critically, the Tribunal rejected the respondent's contention that s 57(1)(b) permits the Chief Psychiatrist to pre-emptively authorise chemical and mechanical restraint in advance of specific incidents, holding that such an interpretation is contrary to the Act's objects, the mental health service delivery principles in Schedule 1, and patient rights under s 15A. The Tribunal also rejected reliance on the Work Health and Safety Act 2012 as an 'other law' authorising restraint under s 57(1)'s opening exception. An incomplete tick-box on a Detaining for Assessment form does not invalidate the detention where the mental health officer gives clear evidence of having formed the requisite reasonable belief under s 17.
The full text is available to signed-in members.