Power to order new trial or quash conviction and direct entry of verdict of acquittal
Quick Take
1Under s 332(1) of the Criminal Code 1924 (Tas), a person indicted for a crime cannot be convicted of another crime except as Chapter XXXIX provides. Aggravated carjacking is not among the crimes with express alternatives in ss 333–339A, so an alternative verdict is available only under s 341.
2Section 341 permits conviction of another crime only where the charged crime, as described in the enactment or as particularised in the count, of necessity involves commission of that other crime. Stealing under s 226(1) requires a dishonest taking with intent to permanently deprive. Neither carjacking nor aggravated carjacking under s 240A, as enacted or as particularised here, necessarily involves those elements, so stealing cannot be left to the jury as an alternative.
3Where a jury, directed under s 332(2), finds the accused not guilty of the indicted crime before returning an impermissible alternative verdict, the accused has been 'acquitted' for the purposes of s 385A(2). The judge's jurisdiction to hear and determine closely related summary complaints therefore survives the quashing of the alternative conviction.