Submissions inviting Court to revisit final judgment following dismissal of proceeding. COSTS
Offer of compromise
Quick Take
1Where a plaintiff recovers only nominal damages for trespass and fails on the substantive controversies, such as claims for aggravated and exemplary damages, a court may, on a broad-brush assessment of the issues, treat the defendant as the substantially successful party and order the plaintiff to pay its costs, particularly where the plaintiff benefited from the defendant's conduct.
2In deciding under r 26.08(3) whether a judgment is 'not more favourable' than an offer of compromise inclusive of costs, a self-represented executor's own time is not treated as costs in the proceeding. On the facts, unsubstantiated or unitemised expenses, mediation costs and the costs of a failed interlocutory appeal were also excluded, leaving only the filing fee.
3Once a final order has been authenticated and perfected, submissions made under leave limited to costs that seek to re-open and re-argue the merits are an impermissible attempt to reopen the proceeding and may be characterised as frivolous, vexatious and an abuse of process.