Supreme Court (General Civil Procedure Rules 2025 (Vic), ord 56
Application by student for judicial review of direction by Deakin University Vice
Chancellor
Quick Take
1A university power to give 'reasonable and lawful directions' to students (Deakin VC Regulations reg 13.4), construed by text, context and purpose, including the university's OHS Act duties to staff, is not impliedly limited to 'operational' directions as to mode, tone or logistics. It is not confined by the student misconduct regime under the Anthony Hordern principle, because forward-looking directions differ in decision-maker, purpose and consequence from backward-looking misconduct outcomes. It may therefore address future conduct of the kind considered at a misconduct hearing, even where misconduct was not substantiated.
2Where a direction updates and replaces an existing direction that is not itself challenged, the content of procedural fairness is assessed by reference to the additional obligations imposed beyond that baseline. On the facts, the minor added burdens, including no in-person approaches to law school staff without a booking, together with the student's prior opportunities to respond in a series of communications and a misconduct hearing, meant no prior notice or hearing was required.
3Restrictions on the manner and channels of a student's communications, rather than on the expression of opinions, can be 'reasonable and proportionate regulation' to foster the wellbeing of students and staff consistent with a Freedom Code modelled on the [name withheld] Model Code. An order in the nature of certiorari is unavailable where the impugned direction's legal effect is spent or about to expire.