Parties enjoyed mixed success at trial on a range of issues
Neither party enjoyed unequivocal success
Quick Take
1Where there is a multiplicity of issues and mixed success, a court may take a pragmatic issue-by-issue approach, apportioning costs by reference to the core categories of dispute and the trial time each occupied; this ordinarily results in the successful party receiving a proportion, but not all, of its costs.
2The court has an inherent power, grounded in its control over its own proceedings rather than statute or equity, to set off a costs order against a security deposit otherwise returnable to the paying party. The discretion turns on fairness and good sense, the public interest, the administration of justice, the parties' conduct and any insolvency. No analytical difference arises where the fund was preserved by injunction rather than paid into court.
3Compensation for use and occupation measured by the terms of a terminated sublease includes both the rent and the outgoings the occupier bargained to pay, applying the lease's own pro-rata mechanism. Pre-judgment interest under ss 58 and 60 of the Supreme Court Act 1986 (Vic) runs on the GST-inclusive sums recovered, although that conclusion was reached without authority or detailed argument to the contrary.