› Application to amend statement of claim – group proceeding – leave to replead
Practice and procedure
› Pleadings
› Knowledge of corporation – attribution – information stored on computer systems
Consumer law
› Unconscionable conduct
› Statutory unconscionability – s 21 Australian Consumer Law – accessorial liability – knowingly concerned
Practice and procedure
› Particulars
› Deferral of particulars until after discovery – best particulars available
Quick Take
1A party alleging a corporation's knowledge must plead the material facts from which knowledge may be inferred and must identify the natural persons whose state of mind is attributable to the company, or plead an appropriate alternative rule of attribution; mere accessibility of information on a corporate system (or references to an undefined executive group) does not establish that any person actually had the knowledge alleged.
2An allegation of accessorial liability (knowingly concerned) for statutory unconscionable conduct or Oil Code contraventions must separately plead intentional participation and actual knowledge of the essential matters, tethered to the specific elements of the primary contravention and the circumstances said to make it unconscionable; a rolled-up plea is impermissible.
3Deferral of particulars until discovery is confined to matters within the defendant's exclusive knowledge; plaintiffs must give the best particulars they can of matters concerning their own businesses and expressly identify information they lack, although systemic business-practice allegations need not always be particularised by reference to each plaintiff. A term implied by law (such as good faith) in a class of contract must be supported by pleaded features of that class, and on the facts the commission agency agreements were insufficiently pleaded.