Interim injunction sought to require hospital to continue providing life
sustaining treatment to patient in ICU with severe traumatic brain injury which had rendered him permanently unconscious
Parens patriae jurisdiction
Quick Take
1The parens patriae jurisdiction can be enlivened by a patient's unconsciousness, but it is exercised cautiously and solely in the best interests of the health, welfare and dignity of the unconscious person, not for the benefit of the hospital or family members, nor according to family members' preferences as to who should assess the patient.
2What constitutes appropriate medical treatment is a medical matter in the first instance. On the facts, where the treating team and an independent specialist from a separate health network agreed that continued ventilation and ICU support was futile and excessively burdensome, there was no serious question to be tried, and no adjournment was warranted to allow the family to obtain a further opinion of their own choosing.
3Obiter (the Charter point was not pursued at the hearing): s 38 of the Charter of Human Rights and Responsibilities Act 2006 should not be construed as making withdrawal of futile, non-beneficial life-sustaining treatment unlawful as incompatible with the right to life (s 9). Such a construction would be inconsistent with s 8 of the Medical Treatment Planning and Decisions Act 2016, which provides that a health practitioner is not required to administer futile or non-beneficial treatment.