Application for leave to appeal from a decision of the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal
Termination of domestic building contract
Where member determined proceeding in favour of owner, with damages to be assessed
Quick Take
1Section 75 of the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 1998 (Vic) permits only the summary dismissal or striking out of all or part of a proceeding; it does not empower VCAT to enter summary judgment for an applicant. The VCAT Act contains no express such power, and the specific power in s 78(2)(b)(i) to determine a proceeding in an applicant's favour arises only where a respondent's conduct unnecessarily disadvantages another party, not merely because the respondent lacks a valid defence.
2In a domestic building dispute, s 53(1) of the Domestic Building Contracts Act 1995 (Vic), read with ss 97 and 98 of the VCAT Act, empowers VCAT to determine the proceeding summarily in an applicant's favour, in a manner akin to summary judgment, provided it accords procedural fairness and gives proper consideration to the matters before it. Procedural fairness then requires notice of the material and arguments, an opportunity to file responding material and an opportunity to make submissions, not a full trial with oral evidence. A Tribunal's mistake as to the source of a power it in fact possesses does not invalidate its decision.
3A VCAT order finally determining liability with damages to be assessed is an 'order' for the purposes of s 148(2) of the VCAT Act, so an application for leave to appeal against it must be made within 28 days. An in-time appeal against the later damages order is confined to the assessment of damages, and on the facts an extension of time was refused where the delay caused potential prejudice to the respondent and the appeal would fail in any event.