› Reference date – payment claim including retention release claim – whether retention release clause creates separate event-based reference date
Administrative Law
› Judicial review
› Adjudication determination – certiorari – jurisdictional error – application to set aside judgment under s 28R of the Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 2002 (Vic)
Building and Construction
› Security of payment
› Adjudicator's obligation to consider provisions of the contract – s 23(2)(b) – adjudicator not bound by superintendent's certificate of practical completion
Administrative Law
› Procedural fairness
› Adjudication – response to s 21(2B) notice – distinction from further submissions requested under s 22(5)(a)
Quick Take
1Under the Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 2002 (Vic), the entitlement to serve a payment claim on and from a reference date is distinct from the adjudicator's determination of the amount payable. Where a contractual monthly reference date supports a payment claim, a disputed component, such as a claim for release of retention, does not deprive the claim of a reference date merely because the contractual conditions for that component may not have been met (applying Southern Han Breakfast Point Pty Ltd (in liq) v Lewence Construction Pty Ltd [2016] HCA 52).
2On the proper construction of an amended AS4902 contract, a retention-release clause (cl 5.4) conditioned on certification of practical completion and receipt of drawings governs the principal's entitlement to security. It does not create a separate event-based reference date. The general payment-claims clause (cl 37.1), which permits claims for 'other moneys then due to the Contractor', supplied the reference date for the retention claim.
3An adjudicator is not bound by a superintendent's certificate, or by its absence. An adjudicator who quotes a contractual condition, identifies its function and decides for himself whether practical completion could and should have been certified has 'considered' the contract under s 23(2)(b), whether or not that conclusion is correct. On the facts, a failure to expressly address a second, minimally argued limb of the clause did not establish non-consideration, applying Ceerose Pty Ltd v A-Civil Aust Pty Ltd [2023] NSWCA 215.