› Strength of prosecution case – complicity – Crimes Act 1958 (Vic) s 323 – weak case supporting exceptional circumstances
Criminal law
› Bail
› Unacceptable risk – flight risk – interference with witnesses – Bail Act 1977 (Vic) ss 4B, 4E
Criminal law
› Bail
› Aboriginal person – definition in s 3 conjunctive – community acceptance – s 3A considerations not engaged
Quick Take
1The definition of 'Aboriginal person' in s 3 of the Bail Act 1977 (Vic) is conjunctive: an applicant must be descended from an Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander, identify as such, and be accepted as such by an Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander community before s 3A considerations apply. Declining to apply s 3A for want of evidence of community acceptance is not a finding that the applicant is not Aboriginal.
2An affidavit may suffice to prove Aboriginality at a bail hearing, but its assertions must carry evidentiary weight and be more than bare assertions. Where Aboriginality is raised only in written submissions, the evidence may be insufficient to engage s 3A.
3On the facts, the weakness of a complicity-based murder (or alternative manslaughter) case was the major factor establishing exceptional circumstances for a Schedule 1 offence. CCTV showed the applicant pinned to the ground by another person when the co-accused allegedly stabbed the deceased, and the incriminating conduct was complicated by her relationship with the principal offender. Combined with CISP availability, family supervision, a first custodial remand and a limited prior history, this was sufficient.