Claims for alleged insolvent trading and breaches of directors’ duties
Quick Take
1Statutory set-off under s 553C of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) is not available against a liquidator's claim under s 588M. Applying the reasoning in Metal Manufactures Pty Ltd v Morton by analogy, the s 588M right arises only once the company is being wound up, so there is no mutuality before the winding up; Smith v Bone must be taken to have been overruled.
2In a retrospective cash-flow insolvency analysis, unpaid tax debts (including GIC and unassessed liabilities) rank no lower than other debts, and the ATO is not to be treated as a voluntary lender. Related-party assurances of 'unlimited' support do not establish solvency unless objectively shown to extend to the liabilities in question. On the facts, the asserted support did not extend to statutory liabilities.
3Rent affected by the Victorian COVID-19 commercial tenancy relief scheme should be treated in an insolvency analysis as reduced or deferred, not as due on the lease terms until a dispute is resolved. A liquidator's failure to account for the scheme diminishes the probative weight of the liquidator's opinion. However, the absence of a cash-flow reconstruction is not fatal, because insolvency is a question of fact decided on all the evidence.