The Court found on the balance of probabilities that Mr Bentley had contravened his supervision order on 11 occasions (including repeated methylamphetamine use and deletion of phone data) but determined that a continuing detention order was not necessary. The Court amended the supervision order for a period of two years, relaxing certain conditions (including curfew and prior-approval requirements for contact with women) on the basis of expert psychiatric evidence that overly restrictive conditions were contributing to stress and thereby increasing reoffending risk. The decision turned on the offender's age (63), the length of time since his last serious offence (2001), expert evidence that his risk could be adequately managed in the community, and the availability of suitable accommodation with a supportive ex-partner.
The full text is available to signed-in members.