The WA Court of Appeal held that when assessing whether breach of an intermediate (non-essential) contractual term is sufficiently serious to justify termination, the court must focus on the consequences of the particular breach and whether it deprived the innocent party of a substantial part of the benefit of the contract, and must not consider the likelihood of future separate breaches of a similar kind — that inquiry belongs to the distinct doctrine of renunciation/repudiation. The Court confirmed that the benefit of the contract must be identified by proper construction of the contract as a whole, not by treating individual clauses as delivering freestanding benefits. On damages, the Court declined to interfere with the trial judge's preference for actual financial statements over budgeted standard costs where the appellant failed to identify specific actual costs that were incurred but omitted from the accounts, and upheld the evaluative discounts applied to future seasons as involving no error of principle.
The full text is available to signed-in members.