The Court of Appeal held that a respondent who actively defended a tribunal recommendation on appeal (including filing a competency challenge) could not avoid a costs order merely because the respondent did not originally seek the recommendation below. The costs order was reduced to two-thirds to reflect the appellant's abandoned amendment raising the 'hurt on duty' construction point. On the question of whether a Suitors' Fund Act indemnity certificate could issue for an appeal from the Police Superannuation Tribunal, the Court left the issue unresolved, noting that no regulation had prescribed the Tribunal under the amended s 2 definition of 'Court', and granted liberty to apply with full argument.
The full text is available to signed-in members, including the 19 later cases that cite this judgment.