The Briginshaw standard of proof applies to disciplinary proceedings against legal practitioners in South Australia, not proof beyond reasonable doubt, even where the allegations involve moral turpitude. A charge of misleading a complaints committee requires proof of intention to mislead; where a practitioner denies such intent and is not cross-examined on the denial, the denial should stand. A pre-trial assertion of innocence to a complaints committee cannot form the basis of a disciplinary charge of misleading the committee after the practitioner is subsequently convicted.
The full text is available to signed-in members, including the 8 later cases that cite this judgment.