A trial judge who feels obliged to redress the balance after defence counsel has advanced fanciful possibilities must confine the qualification to warning against fantastic or completely unreal possibilities, and must not direct the jury to disregard a 'mere possibility' or require that alternative inferences be 'based on the evidence' in a manner that implies the defence must adduce evidence to support them. The laying of two counts — one for attempted possession and one for actual possession — is proper where police have split a drug consignment for a controlled delivery, as the two counts reflect the true criminality.
The full text is available to signed-in members, including the 7 later cases that cite this judgment.